Showing posts with label 2010 World Cup. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2010 World Cup. Show all posts

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Tips for Trevor


Cape Town - The Dalai Lama should not be allowed to raise global issues on South African soil that would impact on the country's standing, Finance Minister Trevor Manuel said on Thursday.

Speaking during a debate at the University of Cape Town, he said not allowing the Dalai Lama into South Africa was "a matter of relations between states".

"To say anything against the Dalai Lama is, in some quarters, equivalent to trying to shoot Bambi," he said.

"Let's put our cards on the table. Who is the Dalai Lama? I've heard him described as a god. I've heard him described as Buddha.

"Is he just the spiritual leader of the Buddhists in Tibet, or is he the one who on March 28, 1969, established a government-in-exile in the same way as Taiwan was established to counter the reality of a single China?"

Manuel said Tibet's history had to be looked at, because the Lamas had been "feudal overlords" in that country.

"The reason why the Dalai Lama wants to be here... is to make a big global political statement about the secession of Tibet from China and he wants to make it on the free soil of South Africa.

"I'm sure he's welcome to come at any other time, but we shouldn't allow him to raise global issues that will impact on the standing of South Africa.

"Quite frankly this has nothing to do with the PSL [Premier Soccer League], it is a matter of relations between states and that's what we have to stand up for."
- SAPA/News24.com



Dear Trevor,

Firstly I want to put on record that I really admire you and in fact I think you are probably the most credible Minister in government today.

A few months ago, I with the rest of South Africa heaved a very, deep sigh of relief when you continued to serve in government after Mbeki. Yes I know your intent to resign was only a matter of due course and respect for the new President but my relief was no less sincere when it was announced you would continue to serve. This is endorsed by the high esteem in which you are held internationally as well as within the South African Business Community.

Imagine my shock when I read the article above on News24.com. It’s on most of the other news sites so I expect it will be a big story in the morning. I have to say you were the last person I expected or thought would agree to deliver the party line to voters. Now that I think about it however in my mind the most credible Ministers in the current cabinet are Finance, Education and Health. So I'm assuming it was a coin toss between you and the Minister of Education as obviously the Minister of Health was not quite in the running.

We obviously know that your remarks at UCT were not off the cuff. Much like the Minister of Health? They were pre scripted and designed to deliver a message. We can only assume that since you did not indicate that these were your personal views that they are the views of Government and the ANC. Yes? No?

The questions you posed were very interesting, and yes I have to say questions I myself have asked. Before I support somebody I really like to know pretty much everything about the candidate. The good, bad and ugly. Very often I go with a view that is not popular but I make sure I research every aspect. You on the other hand pose many questions as to who the Dalai Lama is and his legitimacy yet you offer no viewpoint or conclusion. This is an old ploy to maximise media attention but yet to offer no opinion which could be held against you in the future.

Surly a person as educated as yourself has a very clear view of who the Dalai Lama is and his hereditary/political/religious right?

I do however understand your viewpoint that the 2010 World Cup should not be a platform for political views. However I think it was very naive for government to think that if they sold South Africa as the sparkling light of democracy, African prosperity and success as well as a truly forward thinking economy in order to win the World Cup that minority groups would not try to use the event to voice their opinion.

It’s an acceptable norm for interest groups to be able to voice their opinion in an arena that would afford them maximum media exposure. That's why every protest group on the planet descends on the G8, Davos, Presidential Inaugurations and the odd Royal wedding or two. It’s called Freedom of Speech!

If for example the Pope had been invited, do you not think he would have not taken the opportunity to tell us Africans not to use condoms? Do you think if the Chief Rabbi of Israel was invited he would not comment on Israel’s right to a Jewish homeland? And if in the event Muammar Al- Gaddafi was able to slip in do you not think he would not sprout forth regarding a United States of Africa?

Everybody has an opinion and I think as South Africans we are one of the most authorised populations in the world to be able listen to all sides and then surrender an opinion. What you need to understand is an event such as we are hosting will inevitably become a platform for those seeking a voice. My only regret is that this is something which is obviously not available in the world's most highly regarded democracy. Or so we thought....

What would have made me proud is if the South African government had granted the Dalai Lama his visa and then confronted him with the same questions you posed in your UCT speech. Surely this would have played out 10000% better media wise? IS THAT NOT WHAT TRUE DEMOCRACY IS ALL ABOUT? Everybody gets to be heard?

I have to admire your guts though. Putting up your credibility on the line after Tutu, De Klerk, Mandela, The Nobel Peace Prize Committee, Barbara Hogan, Biko's widow, and a long list of international and local scholars, politicians, social commentators as well as human rights activists have condemned the South African Governments actions. You obviously believe you are right? Yes?

You are the Minister of Finance. What business do you have commenting on an issue such as this? Unless you were asked to? I'm sure you are saying “but what business does Barbara Hogan have commenting.” The difference is you pose questions without answers or a definitive viewpoint. Barbara Hogan has nailed her colours to the mast.

Stick to what you are good at and please try restraining yourself from being used as the most popular political puppet!!!!

The media war has been lost internationally. Charlize Theron was spotted walking though Sandton City today with nothing to do. Queen Rania of Jordan is also supposed to be in town for the conference, lets hope she has had the good sense to flee!!!

This has to be a huge embarrassment to The South African Government? I truly hope you have not been advised by Government communications and PR people because they have miss read the political temperature of most South Africans as well as the international community.

You need to know when to back down!!!! International coverage has turned against you and the Government.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

The Issue of Barbara Hogan


So to say I was surprised by Barbara Hogan's statements regarding the Dalai Lama is an understatement. Why somebody who's appointment as a minister came as a pleasant surprise would undermine her appointment is a mystery to me. She is not a stupid woman so my interest level rose.

To be honest her statements were honest, true and made with an element of embarrassment for her employer. It’s like she just had to speak out no matter what the repercussions. The Prez is obviously pissed as her statements were not authorised, but like issues of conscience you just get to a point when your true heart and mind tells you what is going on is WRONG!

I got the feeling from watching her on TV that either one of the deals of her acceptance of the ministerial post was that she reserves the right to criticise issues she does not agree with or more likely the Dalai Lama issue was a huge eye opener and she realised she had signed up for something that was just not up to the playing field.

Let’s not forget that though the ANC thought this event was going to pass without much incident it has blown up into an international news issue. DO YOU KNOW SOUTH AFRICA IS THE ONLY COUNTRY IN THE WORLD OTHER THAN CHINA TO REFUSE THE DALAI LAMA A VISA EVER?

The decision effects the two most important issues related to government, domestic and foreign policy. From a domestic viewpoint the ANC government has shocked voters and supporters by trying to suppress the views of a suppressed minority. Maybe this is vastly different from a suppressed majority but in my book everybody deserves to be heard.

Lets not forget that her statement only came after Desmond Tutu, FW De Klerk, Mandla Mandela (this was an interesting development, with the chosen one making a very public political statement, doesn't happen often and I couldn’t help but wonder if Nelson was sending a message he could not voice) all criticised the government. The Nobel Peace Prize Committee stood firm with their recipients. And the 2010 Peace conference has now been cancelled.

But more importantly the world now thinks that South Africa is so bedazzled by the investments made by China in our country that we would bar somebody akin to the Pope from entering our democratic country. Who cares what he is here for; I mean the Pope just told the world not to use condoms!!! How much more shit could the Dalai Lama cause? Well evidently quite a bit as he has been banned until after the 2010 World Cup for fear that he will draw attention away from this majestic soccer event.

OK, I'm the first to admit that I'm not gifted but how does a government elected on democratic values, beliefs and convictions justify suppressing the voice of the suppressed minority because it could detract from a sports event. I see Biko, Tambo, and Sisulu rolling over in their graves.

I suspect Barbara Hogan was so shocked by the governments visa issue with the Dalai Lama that she lost the little hope she had that this administration would do the right thing regardless of the financial implications for the country. She has in her short time in office done more for South Africa locally and internationally than her predecessor. Admittedly it’s going to get her fired but I think it was worth it.

Don’t get me wrong, The Prez or should I say ANC Executive have decided she has to go but in light of all the international coverage it would be tantamount to suicide to axe her now. I suspect there will be quite a few more awkward cabinet meetings until the dust settles and she can be despatched with some lame excuse.

I know I’m rambling but I really think we need to support, highlight and encourage people like Barbara Hogan. She has the guts to say when she thinks something is wrong not matter what the implications. And even though I’m sure she did not expect this point to come so early in her career as a minister I salute her for talking her mind.

For some strange reason though through this whole drama I have been thinking how Helen Suzman would have reacted. I think she would have been doing flick flacks through parliament utterly shocked at what she fought for her whole life has been stained by such a pointless yet mammoth event in South African history.

Monday, March 23, 2009

DA on Top of their IT Game


So recently I joined the Twitter revolution. In case you don't know it is probably best not to get involved. Like Facebook it is highly, highly addictive, and like Facebook you start out not having a clue what is going on but within a few days you are asking yourself how you ever lived without it. I can't stress how dangerous Twitter is!!! Mark my words there will be Twitter support groups popping up all over soon with meetings obviously dictated by who has the venue with the strongest 3G or WiFi connection.

Just today Stephen Fry has kept me updated on pretty much every aspect of his latest overseas trip. He really does nothing much else but Tweet (my lingo might be off) all day long. Ryan Seacrest let me know that Benji Madden wants him to get a tattoo to which Perez Hilton suggested a tattoo of Simon Cowell. John Mayer talks a lot but often I can't quite seem to understand what he is saying. I think he might drink and Tweet but don't quote me. (Dweeting) see below. Ashton and Demi are really cool, Ashton hinted at Bruce's wedding by posting a photo of Demi ironing his suite while bending over in a white bikini. Only put two and two together when he told us how he planned to speak Spanish to the customs officials on return at Miami Airport. Britney Spears is cool and lets us know she is having a ball on the tour.

But seriously besides the celebs it is a great way to keep tabs on friends and family basically in real time. Unlike facebook the people you follow are real and not imposter's. So far I have not come across any Twactor's (someone who pretends to be a real life identity on Twitter). Its truly an amazing tool. Just so you don't worry Lance Armstrong also just let me know he is fine and having a glass of wine at a friends house before going back to the US.

But let me get to the original purpose of this story. So I have been very concerned about the fact that the South African Government have not issued H.H. The Dalai Lama with a visa to attend the 2010 World Cup Peace Conference. So after a few glasses of cheap wine I sent Helen Zilla a Dweet (Tweet sent while drunk) to see what her and the DA's take on the situation is. Imagine my surprise when early the next morning she sent me a Tweet with a link to the DA's official take on the situation. I almost fell out of bed. A BIG UP to Helen Zilla and the DA. Awesome communication with voters.

I got to tell you I was very impressed, so much so that I'm now torn between voting for the DA or COPE. Lets not forget that Mosiuoa Lekota did take the time to send me a birthday message on Facebook.

Anyhow check out Twitter if you dare...